Texas Tech went to Stillwater, beat then-No. 25 Oklahoma State 52–27 and improved to 9–1. The reward in Tuesday’s College Football Playoff rankings? The Red Raiders stayed at No. 12.
In our opinion, college football can do better. Alabama, Texas and Tennessee all have two losses and sit ahead of Tech. So does BYU. The committee weighs strength of schedule, head-to-head results and performance against common opponents when teams are comparable. So show us how those factors played out. What did the committee see in those résumés that outweighed a 25-point road win over a ranked team?
Does the number of SEC connections on the 13-member selection committee affect where Texas Tech landed? The CFP’s own roster and recusal list document several ties, including Arkansas athletic director Hunter Yurachek, former Auburn coach Gus Malzahn and former Ole Miss player Wesley Walls. The CFP has school-specific recusal rules, and those connections alone don’t tell us how anyone voted. The committee can answer the question that matters to fans: How did it weigh Tech’s résumé against the three two-loss SEC teams it ranked ahead of the Red Raiders?
Give each Power Four conference four seats on the selection committee, with one additional seat representing all other FBS conferences. That makes 17 seats. ESPN should have no say in who sits on the committee, including who gets nominated or appointed. That would put the four power conferences on equal footing and give the rest of the FBS a voice.
And since ESPN’s hosts like giving money away, here’s a challenge for their on-air picks. Every time an ESPN host gets a pick wrong, that host should donate $1,000 to a food bank in the school’s hometown. Get a Texas Tech pick wrong? The money goes to a food bank in Lubbock.
Texas Tech and Cody Campbell aren’t going away. Campbell played on Tech’s offensive line and pledged $25 million toward the South End Zone and Football Center project. As we reported in our Double Eagle story, his company agreed to sell certain Midland Basin assets to Diamondback Energy and plans to keep drilling on its remaining Reagan County acreage. Here in West Texas, Campbell has already put his name and his money behind the program.
Tech still has Baylor and TCU to play. If Tech wins these two games, the Red Raiders will be in the Big 12 Championship game. The committee has work to do, too. Tell fans what separates No. 12 from the teams above it, and explain what Tech can do on the field to change that. Give a clear explanation other than the trite slogan, “It Just Means More.”
